Four colleagues around a meeting room table, one mid-sentence while the others listen.

Team chemistry: how to measure it, not hope for it

Why do some teams excel under pressure, while others get stuck? It is the question AZ opened with when it wrote about our work together, and the question behind every conversation about team chemistry.

By The PeakPersonality Team

Published on August 29, 2025. Updated on November 1, 2026.

Chemistry is not luck

On paper the squad is strong. In training it looks good. Then the match gets tight, and the team falls apart into eleven individuals. Another team, with less talent, keeps playing for each other until the last minute.

Most people call that difference team chemistry and treat it as luck. We think it can be understood, and to a large extent measured, because it comes from something you can measure: the character of the people in the team.

How AZ uses it

At AZ, the method is used broadly: with the first team, Jong AZ and the under-19s, but also with the coaching staff and the board. Every player, coach and staff member is mapped, so the club can see not just individuals but how they work together.

Insight into character and behaviour helps us to support people in the right way. Whether it is a player, a coach or an employee: if you understand how someone reacts under pressure and where their strengths lie, you create an environment in which people can excel.

Merijn Zeeman, general director of AZ

Every player has a unique profile. By understanding what gives someone energy, how they react under pressure and what kind of guidance works best for them, you can speed up development and improve performance.

Tex Ruskamp, co-founder of PeakPersonality

Quotes translated from Dutch. Read AZ's article.

What team chemistry is, and what it isn't

Team chemistry is not the same as liking each other. Teams of friends can perform badly, and some of the best teams in sport were not close off the pitch.

It rests on two things.

Safety. People dare to ask a question, admit a mistake or try something new without fearing how the others will react. Amy Edmondson of Harvard Business School called this psychological safety in 1999, and Google's large study of its own teams, Project Aristotle, found it was the factor that mattered most for team effectiveness.

Fit. The characters in the team complement each other. Not everyone the same, and not everyone different, but the right mix for what the team has to do. A team needs someone who keeps calm when it gets tense, and someone who goes first when the team falls behind. When everyone has the same strengths, the team has the same blind spot too.

Safety is about the climate in the team. Fit is about the people in it. You need both, and the second one is the one that is usually left to chance.

Why chemistry breaks under pressure

In a calm week, almost any team gets along. Pressure changes that. Under stress, people fall back on their core character: what they are naturally strongest in. The careful player becomes more careful. The fighter fights harder. The one who holds the group together starts organising.

That is why a team can look balanced in training and lose its shape in the final ten minutes. The mix that matters is not how people behave on a good day, but what they fall back on when it counts. And that is exactly what most selection and team-building leaves out.

What it looks like on the pitch

Two examples from our own work.

The penalty corner. At a hockey club in The Hague we worked with, the youth teams kept improving but did not win titles. One of the changes was to link each player's character to their role in the field. The runner for a penalty corner, the player who sprints out at the shooter, became the bravest player, not the fastest. That run is about nerve, not speed. In 2023 two of the club's youth teams became Dutch champions.

The thoughtful midfield. In professional football we have seen teams where the defence and midfield consist only of thoughtful, careful characters. The result: the ball goes wide and back, and nobody takes the risk forward. Such a team needs at least one player who stirs things up when things go wrong and leads the way. The same question applies to the coach. If the coach is naturally cautious and the club wants to play forward, it is worth asking whether that is a match.

Neither is about talent. In both cases the players were good enough. What changed was who did what, based on how they act under pressure.

The same questions at work

As AZ's article puts it, the insights turn out to be at least as valuable outside sport. How do you make sure a team works together well? Which kind of leadership suits which person? And how do you have the right conversation when you hire and onboard new talent?

Many organisations make those decisions on conversations, feeling and experience. Objective insight into character does not replace that; it gives those conversations something to stand on, in hiring and onboarding, team development and leadership.

The patterns are the same as on the pitch, with different words. A team of careful, analytical people makes few mistakes and few bold decisions. A team where everyone leads struggles to finish anything. A new manager whose character clashes with the team's can lose them in a few months without anyone being able to say why. These are not failures of skill or effort. They are questions of fit, and they show the moment the pressure goes up.

Fit starts before someone joins. More on that in hiring for character.

How we measure it

Every member of the team completes a scientifically validated questionnaire. It ranks 24 character strengths, such as bravery, perseverance, teamwork and leadership, from most to least typical for that person, and we translate them into the performance strengths that matter in a high-pressure setting. We do not score people as good or bad. There is no winning profile. The focus is on what makes people strong, not on what they lack: what each person is strongest in, and what they will fall back on under pressure.

In the dashboard, coaches, managers and HR see the whole team at once:

  • Where people click and where they clash. Which pairs and lines share the same strengths, and which are far apart.
  • What the team is missing. For example, nobody whose strengths lie in leading under adversity, or in keeping calm when it gets tense.
  • How the coach or manager fits the team. A leader's strengths shape how they react under pressure, and how the team reacts to them.
  • What happens if you change the line-up. Scenarios to test which combinations work before you try them in a match, or in a project.

What to do with it on Monday morning

Knowing your team's chemistry is only useful if it changes what you do. Four things that work:

  1. Talk about each other's top strengths, openly. When people know what their teammates are strongest in, a different reaction under pressure stops being a surprise, and stops being personal.
  2. Give the pressure moments to the right people. Who takes the penalty, who speaks first after a setback, who leads the difficult client meeting. Base it on character, not on seniority or habit.
  3. Build pairs and lines on purpose. Put a calm head next to a fighter. Make sure a careful line has at least one person who goes forward.
  4. Agree on the words for bad moments. What helps one person recover after a mistake makes another worse. A shared language for those moments is one of the fastest ways to build safety.

Common questions

Can you really measure team chemistry?
Not as a single number. You can measure what it is made of: the character of each person and how those characters combine. That turns a vague feeling into something a team can talk about and act on.

Is team chemistry the same as psychological safety?
Psychological safety is a large part of it: the climate in which people dare to speak up. The other part is fit, whether the characters in the team complement each other. A team can feel safe and still lack someone who leads when it goes wrong.

Do the most similar teams have the best chemistry?
No. People who are alike get along easily, but they also share the same blind spots. Good chemistry usually means a team where people are different in the right places.

Who uses this?
Professional clubs and national federations in sport, and management teams and HR in business. At AZ it runs from the first team and the youth academy to the staff and the board.

Can you build chemistry in a new team?
Yes, and a new team is the best moment to start. Mapping the characters early means you do not have to wait for the first crisis to find out how people react.

Sources & References

  • AZ (2026). AZ x PeakPersonality: Succes begint bij de mens achter de prestatie. az.nl, 14 October 2026.
  • Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.
  • Google re:Work. Guide: Understand team effectiveness (Project Aristotle).
  • Couwenbergh, P. (2024). 'Onder druk valt een sporter terug op zijn kernkarakter'. Het Financieele Dagblad, 22 August 2024.

Want to see the chemistry in your own team?