Pieces on a chess board, mid-game.

Hiring for character: what an interview misses

A CV tells you what someone has done. An interview tells you how well they present themselves in an hour. Neither tells you how they act the first time it gets tense.

By The PeakPersonality Team

Published on August 29, 2025. Updated on November 1, 2026.

Why good hires still go wrong

The deadline that slips, the match that turns, the client who is angry. How does this person react, and does that fit the team they are joining? Most hiring leaves that question to feeling. It does not have to.

When a hire fails, it is rarely because the person could not do the work. Skills were checked. Experience was checked. What was not checked is how they work with others when it counts: how they take a setback, whether they lead or wait, what they need from a manager, and how that sits with the team around them.

Those are questions of character, and a standard interview is poor at finding them. Candidates prepare, and they should. Interviewers like people who are like themselves. And the conversation tends to go where it is comfortable, which is rarely where the risk is.

What the research says about interviews

Interviews are not the problem. The kind of interview is.

The largest recent review of how well selection methods predict job performance (Sackett and colleagues, 2022) found structured interviews, where every candidate gets the same well-chosen questions, among the strongest predictors there are. Unstructured interviews, the friendly conversation that goes wherever it goes, predicted roughly half as well.

So the gain is not in adding a test. It is in asking better questions, and asking them about the things that matter for this role and this team. That is where character comes in.

How AZ uses it

At AZ, character is part of how the club looks at people: in the first team, the academy, the coaching staff and the board. As AZ's article puts it, the insights turn out to be at least as valuable outside sport: how do you have the right conversation when you hire and onboard new talent?

Insight into character and behaviour helps us to support people in the right way. Whether it is a player, a coach or an employee: if you understand how someone reacts under pressure and where their strengths lie, you create an environment in which people can excel.

Merijn Zeeman, general director of AZ

Quote translated from Dutch. Read AZ's article.

Character is not a pass mark

This is where a lot of personality testing in hiring goes wrong, so it is worth being clear.

There is no winning profile. A strengths profile does not say whether someone is good or bad, or whether they should get the job. It says what they are strongest in and what they will fall back on under pressure. That is useful in the conversation, and it is the wrong tool for a yes or no.

So we do not use it to filter candidates out. We use it to make the interview about the right things, and to make sure the person who is hired gets off to a good start.

Fit, not sameness

"Culture fit" often turns into hiring people who are like the people already there. That feels safe and creates a team with one blind spot. The same is true on the pitch: a midfield of careful, thoughtful players rarely takes the risk forward.

The better question is what the team is missing. If a management team is strong in analysis and caution, the next hire who brings drive and decisiveness adds more than another careful analyst, even if the analyst interviews better. Seeing the team's strengths next to the candidate's makes that question concrete. More on this in team chemistry.

How we use it

The candidate completes the same scientifically validated questionnaire as everyone else in the team. It ranks 24 character strengths, such as bravery, perseverance, teamwork and leadership, from most to least typical for that person, and we translate them into the performance strengths that matter in a high-pressure setting. The candidate sees their own profile.

From there:

  • Questions for the interview. The profile points to where to dig: for a strength that is very present, ask how it shows up under pressure; for one that is far down, ask what they do when the role asks for it. Every candidate for the role gets the same kind of questions, which is what makes an interview structured.
  • The candidate next to the team. Where they would add something, where they would double up, and how they would sit with their manager.
  • Onboarding from day one. The first conversations with a new hire start from what they are strongest in and what they need from a manager, instead of finding out after three months. People who get to use their top strengths at work report more positive experiences at work (Harzer and Ruch, 2013), and the first weeks are when that pattern is set.

What to do in your next hiring round

  1. Decide what the role needs under pressure, before you meet anyone. Not a list of nice qualities, but the two or three moments that make or break the job.
  2. Write the questions down, and ask every candidate the same ones. Ask for real examples: "Tell me about the last time…", not "How would you…".
  3. Look at the team before the candidate. What is already there in abundance, and what is missing? Hire for the gap, not for the mirror.
  4. Use the interview to test the profile, not to confirm it. If someone's profile says perseverance, ask about the time they gave up. The real person is always more interesting than the report.
  5. Carry it into the first week. Share what you learned with their manager, and with the new hire. The best onboarding starts from what someone is strongest in.

Common questions

Can you use a personality questionnaire to select candidates?
Not on its own, and not as a pass mark. A strengths profile describes a person; it does not rank them against each other. Used to shape a structured interview and to plan onboarding, it adds a lot. Used as a filter, it does more harm than good.

Doesn't the candidate just give the answers they think you want?
Less than you might think. The questionnaire ranks strengths against each other, so you cannot score high on everything. And because the profile is used to ask better questions rather than to decide, there is little to gain from gaming it.

What does the candidate get out of it?
Their own profile, and a conversation about things that matter to them. Many candidates find that the most useful part of the process, whether or not they get the job.

Is this only for sport?
No. Clubs use it for players, coaches and staff, and organisations use it for hiring and onboarding in exactly the same way. The questions are the same: how does this person act under pressure, and what does this team need?

What about privacy?
A candidate's profile is personal data. They choose to complete the questionnaire, they see their own results, and the profile is only used for the role they applied for.

Sources & References

  • AZ (2026). AZ x PeakPersonality: Succes begint bij de mens achter de prestatie. az.nl, 14 October 2026.
  • Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., & Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040–2068.
  • Harzer, C., & Ruch, W. (2013). The application of signature character strengths and positive experiences at work. Journal of Happiness Studies, 14(3), 965–983.